Pretty Little Liars may have ended, but juicy set gossip from the set continues to be spilled! Several of the show’s main characters just revealed some scandalous makeup chair secrets we never saw coming.

Appearing on Ellen DeGeneres’ Show Me More Show, the cast was subject to a rousing game ofNever Have I Ever.” Presented with statements like “Never have I ever hooked up on set” (they all have, FYI), “Never have I ever made an assistant cry” (Shay Mitchell has), and “Never have I ever lied about my age” (tsk, tsk, Sasha Pieterse), the girls revealed all, or most.

The game’s most shocking moment, however, came when Lucy Hale, Shay Mitchell, and Troian Bellisario flipped their paddle to “I have,” when asked about if they’ve ever had to cover up a hickey with makeup. Hale explained her response was obviously for the sake of the show and so her parents wouldn’t see. “I’ve got very sensitive skin,” she said.

While she didn’t reveal who her makeout partner was, she DID admit to having a crush on her onscreen love Ezra, played by actor Ian Harding, back in season one. Oh, my!

What do you think of the PLL‘s cast confessions? Tell us @BritandCo!

(Photos via Frazer Harrison + Andrew Toth/Getty)