We have to give Black Garlic Doritos the title of creepiest Halloween treat, and Candy Corn Oreos were a thing we never thought would exist, but when it comes to your new fave Halloween candy, we’re gonna guess that M&M’s Boo-terscotch flavor may in fact take the #1 spot.

M&M's Boo-terscotch

A butterscotch take on the classic M&M’s candy, Delish claims they taste just like Butterbeer. Mmm! Although, one taster over at PopSugar deemed them “terror-able,” saying they are too sweet and the artificial flavors are too obvious. Boo!

Available exclusively at Target for the Halloween season, be sure to try them out before they disappear.

Have you tried M&M’s Boo-terscotch flavor? Tweet us @BritandCo!

(h/t PopSugar; photo via M&M’s)