Pumpkin spice fever is upon us, and the flavor/scent has made its splash everywhere from bathtubs to armpits. One place you sadly won’t be seeing it, however, is in your Too Faced shadows.

You may have seen a photo floating around the internet of what looks to be a pumpkin spice-themed Too Faced eyeshadow palette. Since the brand is known for their beauty scented with peaches and cream, peanut butter and jelly, and chocolate, it’s not that much of a stretch to believe that the brand really would drop a PSL-inspired product. The original pic was from Insta user Stardustgirl, who captioned her creation, “Photoshop made me do it! Hey, there’s PSL everything else…”

Even Too Faced co-founder Jerrod Blandino regrammed the image, and in the caption said, “Hysterical. My fans have the best ideas!” Yep, it’s just fan art. Womp womp.

Based on overwhelmingly positive fan reactions to the pic — everything from “DO IT PLS” to “Can we make this a thing? Asking for a friend” — Blandino could decide to create and release it next year. For now, though, it’ll have to stay a fantasy.

Would you like a pumpkin spice palette? What’s your favorite pumpkin spice product? Tell us @BritandCo!

(Photos via Vivien Killilea/Getty, Instagram)