Elevating your eyebrow game is a simple, impactful way to add an air of polish to your look. A swipe of an inky gel or a couple strokes of a precise pencil can totally change the makeup game for you, but it can be tough finding your holy grail product with so many to choose from. Have no fear, though — the Brit + Co beauty team is here to share our absolute favorite, personally vetted brow products with you. Read on to learn which ones we swear by and why.

Zoey Washington, Senior Fashion and Beauty Editor:I love the two-in-one treStiQue Brow Pencil ($24) in Latte for everyday use. The tinted brow gel adds just the right amount of definition to my brows without looking over-the-top or like I’m trying to make a statement. On nights when I really want to turn up the volume, I use the triangular pencil to amplify the pigment and fill out my shape. Unlike other formulas that simply add a clear gel to my eyebrows, it has a subtle pigment that gives me the ideal sculpted boy brow.”

Sharon Tanenbaum, Executive Editor, Style: “For better or worse, I have intense eyebrows. After shaping them into a too-thin shape exactly once, I have learned to love their fullness (if not their unpredictability). The LANCÔME Sourcils Styler Brow Styler ($27) provides just the right amount of hold to tame the strays, and the natural pigment plumps up the hairs to fill in any sparse areas. Plus, celeb makeup artist Nick Barose uses it to groom Lupita Nyong’o’s arches, so I am in worthy company.”

Beth Wischnia, Beauty Editor: “I used 100% Pure Green Tea Fiber Brow Builder ($22) for the first time about a year ago, and nothing else since. The medium brown shade is perfect for my dark eyebrows but still manages to work well against my fair skintone — it’s definitely bold, but still looks soft and never harsh. I have never found a brow gel formula that is so lightweight but actually builds up the structure of your eyebrows at the same time. I’m completely hooked.”

Want more makeup must-haves? Follow us on Pinterest!

Brit + Co may at times use affiliate links to promote products sold by others, but always offers genuine editorial recommendations.