Naya Rivera and David Spade, the couple that surprised us all earlier this year with a hookup that came seemingly out of the blue, may be donezo — at least if social media is any indicator.

Rumors are swirling that the pair, who initially began dating back in early April, has called it quits. The mill began churning after fans noticed both Spade and Rivera no longer appeared to be following one another on social media, which, in today’s modern times, is as good an indicator as any that there may be trouble in paradise.

Not that the actors really ever made things super official to begin with: The closest they came to speaking out on their union was when Rivera posted a joking video to Instagram stories of herself saying, “Holy sh*t guys, the Easter bunny and the f*cking tooth fairy are for sure dating. I just saw them.”

Adding fuel to the flame are the “likes” Rivera has been doling out on more than a few of ex-husband Ryan Dorsey’s most recent pics.

Fan suspicions seemed to be further confirmed when Spade was spotted out and about among a group of women, including Real Housewives of Miami star Joanna Krupa, with Rivera nowhere in sight.

Though it could merely be a matter of coincidence, US Weekly’s eyewitness source seems to think otherwise.

Here’s to hoping that both of them are happy either way!

Do you think these two have called things off? Let us know over @BritandCo.

(h/t US; photos via Alberto E. Rodriguez + Tommaso Boddi/Getty)