When it comes to Halloween, there’s a lot of pressure to pick the perfect costume. Do you go the silly route, like Channing Tatum, and dress up like a purple unicorn, or keep it more classic, like Alicia Silverstone, who stepped back into her Clueless Cher Horowitz plaid? Sarah Michelle Gellar wouldn’t let herself be confined to just one look. In fact, she was as many as three… all at once!

Taking to Instagram, the Foodstirs creator showed off a mashup of Halloween makeup that could only be described as magical.

Consisting of silver sequin sparkle hair with rainbow ends, colored eyelashes, and a netted forehead, there was no telling exactly what she was, per say — but it didn’t matter.

“Am I a unicorn? Am I a mermaid? Am I part showgirl?!? Whatever I am, I’m ready to support my favorite charity @goodplusfdn (a non-profit providing goods and services to families in need). Oh yeah, and I love Halloween,” she wrote.

We got a better look at her insane beauty transformation from makeup artist David De Leon, who called her a “human rainbow.”

Honestly, this tops even Jenna Dewan Tatum’s sparkle unicorn look from last year! Still, we can’t help but think… how on EARTH is she ever going to get those sparkles out of her hair!?

What do you think of SMG’s makeup? Let us know over @BritandCo.

(Photo via Cindy Ord + Matt Winkelmeyer/Getty)