Becca Cosmetics is pretty much the reigning authority on highlighter. It’s hard to imagine anything better for your cheekbones than Champagne Pop ($38)… but somehow, Becca has found a way.

Becca is letting fans choose their next hightlighter — and one option is GREEN. The proper name is Golden Mint, and it has the pale, pastel shimmer of a stick of Doublemint gum. The other is the sandstone-hued Smoky Quartz, which looks like it could double up as a blush.

The beauty company posted a pic of the two possible releases with the caption: “We’re glowing head-to-head with two brand new highlighter shades! We want YOU to choose our #BECCAShimmeringSurprise by telling us who you want to win – #TeamGoldenMint or #TeamSmokyQuartz? Smoky Quartz has taken the lead, but is Golden Mint your new must-have? Have your say by voting NOW on our Instagram Story.”

If you want to contribute, you can vote for your favorite hue here.

If the anxiety of choosing between rose and mint is too great, however, there’s one more launch that’s NOT up for a vote. Becca is also releasing a new Shimmering Skin Perfector in Lilac Geode, a lavender-pink color with a golden/pearly finish, that’s said to be universally flattering. It’ll be available exclusively on on August 20 and on September 24. You might want to have your wallets ready come Sunday, because this one might very well sell out.

What do you think of the new Becca powders? Are you #TeamGoldenMint or #TeamSmokyQuartz? Tell us @BritandCo!

(Photos via Becca Cosmetics + Becca Cosmetics/Instagram)