5 Incredible New September Shows We Can't Shut Up About

Only Murders in the Building Season 5 — Stream on Hulu September 9, 2025

Who in their right mind isn’t currently obsessing over Only Murders in the Building? I’m all for the unique cast, which includes an unlikely (yet adorable) ensemble of Selena Gomez, Martin Short, and Meryl Streep. Plus, the plot somehow manages to become more and more riveting with each passing season, so I can’t wait for the next installment, which will air Sept 9th, on Hulu. Watch our interview with Michael Cyril Creighton now!

The Girlfriend — Stream on Prime Video September 10, 2025

Man, Olivia Cooke has been seriously killing it lately! I remember when I first saw her on screen, in Bates Motel, where she played the kind-hearted Emma, whose moral values contrasted significantly with the more sinister central characters. Now, she’ll be tackling a more sinister role herself, in the psychological thriller, The Girlfriend, which will be premiering on Prime Video September 10th. It explores the complex, yet less-talked-about, dynamic shared between girlfriends and their boyfriends’ mothers. I always found this dynamic to be quite interesting, yet underexplored, so this show is a must-watch for me, personally.

The Morning Show Season 4 — Streaming on Apple TV September 17, 2025

Anyone else addicted to The Morning Show? The first season was television gold IMO, while the other seasons…let’s just say they were an entertaining trainwreck. But I love me a mess, and that’s where The Morning Show comes in. With its high-stakes plotline, star-studded cast, and the sleekest shots of NYC you’ll ever see, it’s a 10 out of 10 binge for me. Catch season 4 of the series on September 17th.

Slow Horses Season 5 — Stream On Apple TV+ September 24, 2025

Slow Horses is returning for a 5th season on Apple TV+, and fans seriously cannot wait. (Proof that Olivia Cooke is crushing it on the small screen. With House of Dragon, Girlfriend, and Slow Horses, it’s about time she’s getting the acclaim and adoration she’s always deserved!)

The series centers around a ragtag bunch of misfits who are forced into the “dumping grounds” of the CIA, and are fighting tooth and nail to be taken seriously in a world where they’re labeled the ultimate losers. Can they prove to others, as well as themselves, wrong? Find out September 24.

Which show are you most looking forward to?

House of Guinness — Stream on Netflix September 25, 2025

The powerhouse behind Peaky Blinders is back to deliver another riveting period piece, this time centered around the Guinness dynasty. Ever wonder about the complex backstory behind the most famous Irish beer of all time? HOG will explore the tragic succession story of the Guinness Dynasty, set in 1800s Ireland. Peaky Blinders meets Succession? Don’t mind if I do! The series will premiere on Netflix on the 25th of this month.