How often do you see images in magazines or online of beautiful women wearing shades of lipstick that you swoon over, only to find out trying to wear it IRL ends up being a total bust?! This year鈥檚 Pantone Colors , a light Rose Quartz and pale Serenity blue, had us curious about how exactly you鈥檇 actually wear them when it comes to beauty. Then, Pantone answered with its 2016 Sephora collaboration , a makeup line that included a gorgeous pastel eyeshadow palette (鈥渓ovely!,鈥 we thought) a collection of tinted lip glosses (we鈥檙e already sold on the watercolor lip look) and two pastel lipsticks. Yes, eyebrows were raised at the latter. Of course, we had to try 鈥檈m.

pl1

I decided to purchase the Sephora + Pantone Universe Layer Lipstick in Rose Quartz ($18) because it appeared to be the more wearable hue, along with two other variations of pastel lipstick, and challenged two gals here in our office with completely different skin tones 鈥 Brenda , our Community Marketing Associate with a fair skin tone, and Angela , our Community Editor with an olive skin tone 鈥 to give these shades a go and report back. The challenge was to take home each lipstick and really try to make them work with their wardrobe, jibe with their personality and fit within their daily makeup routine. Both veteran red lipstick wearers, these two gals were perfect to call in for a perspective that could cover slightly different ends of the spectrum. Here鈥檚 how it went.

Pastel Lipstick 1: Maybelline in Lilac Flush

lip1

I came across Maybelline Color Sensational Rebel Bloom Barely Bloomed in Lilac Flush ($8) at a local Ulta store and was blown away by how pretty the pigment is. The light orchid hue has a slight satin finish that leaves your lips looking more hydrated, which I felt was a good (read: safe) place to start on this pastel lipstick challenge.

ba1

Brenda: 鈥淚鈥檓 a solid lover of red lipstick and deep berry shades, so this pale lilac lip color took a little getting used to. But as soon I gave it a chance, I found a new lipstick love. It matched well with my pale skin tone and bright hair, and I had no trouble finding an outfit in my closet that paired well with the color. I would totally buy this color again for spring when it鈥檚 all about pastels!鈥

a1

Angela: 鈥淭his color made me so happy, I was inspired to wear all of my favorite articles of clothing (chambray shirt + tight black skirt + rhinestone tights + sneaker wedges), which made me even happier.鈥

鈥淚 felt like a more fun and adventurous version of myself! While the color is nowhere near as bright and bold as Nicki Minaj鈥檚 lipstick (<3), I felt like I was channeling a tiny bit of her when I was wearing it.鈥

Pastel Lipstick 2: Make Up For Ever in Satin Bright Orange

l2

The coral pigment in this Make Up For Ever Rouge Artist Intense Color Lipstick in Satin Bright Orange ($20) is soft enough to be considered a pastel, and with slightly warm undertones, it鈥檚 a more versatile hue 鈥 at least in my opinion. Let鈥檚 see what the gals think!

lb2

Brenda: 鈥淟ike I鈥檝e said, I鈥檓 a dark berry, bold red lipstick kind of girl so it may come as a shock, but I don鈥檛 own ANY coral lipsticks. So, this orange-y coral shade was a whole new world for me. I immediately took a liking to the color as soon as I swiped some on, only to look down and realize I would definitely need an outfit change. As much as I love my red plaid button-down, it just does NOT go with a coral lip. It was fun to wear out and about and for some reason, it reminded me of summer and sandy beaches so it put a little pep in my step just because of the memory. Of all three shades I tried, this one was definitely my favorite. I could see myself rocking this shade all throughout spring and summer.鈥

al2

Angela: 鈥淭his color was so bright and ORANGE, so I felt like I couldn鈥檛 wear any clashing colors with it, hence the giant white sweater. At first I felt super self conscious 鈥 It was like nothing I had ever worn and I was convinced it was very out of season. But then I started getting compliments on it and that felt pretty great!鈥

鈥淲hile wearing this lipstick, a very cute and friendly stranger walked me from the office to my train stop (10 minutes) because he just wanted to chat. A drinks date turned to tacos. A friendly construction worker escorted me across the street for no reason. I鈥檓 not saying this lipstick is magical, but I鈥檓 keeping it forever and wearing it at least twice a week, just in case. Needless to say, I now own this color!鈥

Pastel Lipstick 3: Sephora x Pantone in Rose Quartz

s1

The hue that started it all, Sephora + Pantone Universe Color of the Year Lipstick ($18), appears to be a light pink from the image but when you put it on actually has an extreme paleness to it, almost giving the illusion of a white pigment.

bl3

Brenda: 鈥淚 really tried to rock this color, but everything I tried just seemed to make it look worse. I changed my outfit three different times, played around with different eyeshadows, blushes and bronzers to try to make it look better, but nothing seemed to work. I ended up blotting a lot of it off so it was a really light pigment as I walked out the door. Sad, I know, but I just felt way too self-conscious to fully wear it in public. With my super pale skin, it kinda made me look like I was dead. Definitely not a good look for me. You won鈥檛 catch me rocking this shade again anytime soon鈥

an3

Angela: 鈥淭he lipstick was so bizarre looking that I felt like I needed to prove to the world that I was a normal person. I played it safe and wore my preppiest sweater. At best, this lipstick looked like I smeared strawberry ice cream all over my lips. At worst鈥 IDK. I never really believed that lip prints were as unique as fingerprints until I wore this lipstick 鈥 you could see EVERY line in my lips.鈥

I, as well as a couple other gals in the office, just had to try this color out as well 鈥 it can鈥檛 possibly be that bad, right?

lall

or鈥 RIGHT! I think we will leave this hue to high-fashion models and Instagram It girls to pull off. The overall consensus on this hue: NOT WEARABLE IRL!

Well, I have to say that ultimately this pastel lipstick challenge was a huge success! For the most part, wearing pastel lipstick can have surprising results that one would not expect鈥 except for Rose Quartz. It鈥檚 pretty and all, but def for the runway, not the real world!

In my perfect world we would try these lip hues on every skin type, so we鈥檇 LOVE for you to tag your images of your results wearing similar shades and tell us what you think on Instagram !