Free Trial for 120+ Creative Classes

Search & Section Navigation

Brit + Co Logo

Sign In

Shopping

Style NewsTrends & InspoShoes & AccessoriesBest Beauty ProductsHome DecorGift Guides

Self Care

Beauty & Skincare NailsHairMakeupHealthOrganization & CleaningFinancial WellnessA Better Work LifeCreativity & DIY

Celebrity

Celeb StyleRed Carpet Celebrity Couples

Entertainment

TV ShowsMoviesBooksMusic

HOROSCOPES

HoroscopesAsk An AstrologerZodiac Signs

Food

Food News & Menu UpdatesRecipesHealthy EatingAppetizersDessertsCocktails

More

TravelHolidaysRelationships & ParentingGamesBrit + Co PicksSelfmadeDIY ClassesDIY GuidesVideos

Shopping

Self-Care

Celebrity

Entertainment

Horoscopes

Food

Travel

Holidays

Relationships & Parenting

Games

Brit + Co Picks

Selfmade

DIY Classes

DIY Guides

Videos

AboutPressAdvertise With UsClassesCareersContactDo Not Sell My Info

STAY CONNECTED WITH BRIT+CO

  1. Home
  2. Food
  3. Recipes

Our ode to PB&J continues this week with a dessert mash-up of the classic sandwich. What’s not to like here? Peanut butter and jelly? Good. Cookies and ice cream? Good. Combine them all together and you have a delightful dish that you may find yourself eating for lunch instead of the traditional sandwich. And if you do, you will be the envy of all the other kids at lunch, er, the envy of all your co-workers at the office ;)

I Scream, You Scream, We All Scream for PB&J Ice Cream Sandwiches!

I Scream, You Scream, We All Scream for PB&J Ice Cream Sandwiches!

By Lauren WeemsApr 26, 2013

Lauren Weems

Lauren Weems is a stylist and floral designer for wedding, commercial, and editorial photo shoots. When she's not dreaming up ideas for her company Adorned, Lauren is most likely planning her next travel adventure or dinner party.

See Full Bio

Follow:

Recommended for you

Our ode to PB&J continues this week with a dessert mash-up of the classic sandwich. What’s not to like here? Peanut butter and jelly? Good. Cookies and ice cream? Good. Combine them all together and you have a delightful dish that you may find yourself eating for lunch instead of the traditional sandwich. And if you do, you will be the envy of all the other kids at lunch, er, the envy of all your co-workers at the office ;)


Who says PB&J can’t be for adults too? We think you’re never too old to remix a childhood favorite into something your adult taste buds love.

Ingredients:

Peanut Butter Oatmeal Cookies:
– 1/2 cup shortening

– 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened

– 1 cup packed brown sugar

– 3/4 cup white sugar

– 1 cup peanut butter

– 2 eggs

– 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour

– 2 teaspoons baking soda- 1 teaspoon salt

– 1 cup quick-cooking oats

Jelly Ice Cream:
– 1 pint vanilla ice cream

– 1 jar of your favorite jelly or berry preserve

Not up for making your own peanut butter cookies from scratch? You can always buy cookie dough and add in peanut butter chips – we won’t tell! :)

Start by preheating the oven to 350 degrees F. In a large bowl, cream the shortening, butter, brown sugar, white sugar, and peanut butter. Mix until blended. Beat in the eggs one at a time until well blended.

Combine the flour, baking soda, and salt in a medium bowl.

Dump half the dry mixture into the creamed mixture; once it’s been absorbed, mix in the remaining half. Stir in the oats until just combined.

Drop by tablespoonfuls onto greased cookie sheets.

Bake for 13 minutes in the preheated oven, or until just lightly browned. Don’t over-bake! However, we do want these to be firm enough to hold the ice cream in the middle.

While the cookies are cooling, scoop your vanilla ice cream into a bowl. For every scoop, add a tablespoon of jelly. Use a small spatula to spread some of the jelly ice cream mixture onto a cookie.

Press another cookie on top. Place them on a plate in the freezer as you go.

Serve immediately, or let them firm up in the freezer for 90 minutes.

This is a great dessert to serve at parties or any event because you can make it ahead of time and leave it in the freezer until you are ready to serve it.

Yummy! After much “research taste-testing”, our testers all agreed they LOVED how the cookies tasted cold after having been in the freezer to firm up the ice cream part.

First you take the peanuts and you mash them, you mash them…

Then you take the grapes and you crush them, you crush them…

Try not to eat them all up before your guests arrive. Ok, you can sneak just one.

Which of our PB&J recipes this week has been your favorite? What flavor of jelly do you like best with your PB&J Ice Cream Sandwiches? Talk to us in the comments below!

dessert recipesice creamsweets

The Conversation (0)

Reviews:

Signup

The Latest

Sponsored

Meet the Inspiring Founder Behind A New Grief Collective

Theresa Gonzalez

Aug 26, 2022

Fashion

Amanda Perna Left Calvin Klein For Sequins & Feathers. She Has No Regrets.

Theresa Gonzalez

Nov 10, 2026

Parenting

This Life-Changing Hack Relieved My Mental Load For Good

Theresa Gonzalez

Apr 13, 2026

Astrology

Nebula Reviews: Psychic Readings That Offer More Than Just Predictions

Theresa Gonzalez

Feb 05, 2026

A Better Work Life

How To Create A Consistent And Authentic Brand Story On Social

Theresa Gonzalez

May 25, 2023

Make Your Inbox Your Happy Place

Get freebies, inspo, & more delivered to you.

This field is required.

Email is invalid.

You subscribed successfully!

Something went wrong!

Sign up for our newsletter and never miss out!

This field is required.

Email is invalid.

You subscribed successfully!

Something went wrong!

The Top 5

Missing 'The Other Bennet Sister'? BritBox Is Already Adapting Another Jane Austen Book

Nov 12, 2026

11 New Costco Finds To Try In November Before They Sell Out

Nov 15, 2026

25 Thoughts I Had After Watching 'The Family Stone' For The First Time

Nov 12, 2026

The 10 Best Trader Joe's Cheeses, Ranked

Nov 14, 2026

Ella Bright is FINALLY in a New Movie!

Nov 13, 2026

EXPLORE MORE OF BRIT + CO

Selfmade

A business accelerator for early-stage female founders with live workshops, 1:1 mentoring, online courses, and curated business support. Visit

Subscribe to B+C

Get your weekly dose of inspo, pop culture, and creativity — straight to your inbox. Subscribe to the Brit + Co newsletter! Visit

Classes

Explore 120+ Creative Courses in our All-Access Pass or feed your creativity with 45+ B+C Baking + Cooking Bundle . Visit

More For You

test var 2026-09-20

Mikhail Nilov/Pexels

Missing 'The Other Bennet Sister'? BritBox Is Already Adapting Another Jane Austen Book

Chloe Williams​

Nov 12, 2026

Huge news for BritBox and Jane Austen fans: on the heels of The Other Bennet Sister, we're getting a brand new TV show inspired by Persuasion. The Other Elliot Sister is coming to BritBox soon and will follow another overlooked sister in the Jane Austen universe as the next installment of the brand new Austen Untold anthology franchise series. Think American Horror Story, but less horror and much ... Keep reading

Keep Reading Show less

How To Make Your Home Smell Like A Five-Star Hotel

Aura House

How To Make Your Home Smell Like A Five-Star Hotel

Brit + Co

Nov 05, 2026

Scent is so closely tied to memory that a single whiff can take you right back to that dream vacation. So why not make your home feel like your favorite getaway? The Aura House collection is a great place to start. Every nontoxic fragrance is expertly crafted and inspired by iconic hotels and destinations around the world. Bestsellers Collins, Coast and Dubai each capture a very different kind of ... Keep reading

Lily Craigen/Sally Flegg, Courtesy of Netflix; Amazon

Meet the Cast of Netflix's New Hockey Romance 'Icebreaker'

Chloe Williams​

Sep 28, 2026

Netflix is finally adapting one of the OG BookTok favorite hockey romance shows: Icebreaker. It's no surprise that with the success of Off-Campus and Heated Rivalry, TV fans are clamoring for more hockey romance shows.The story follows Anastasia Allen, who's a competitive figure skater determined to become an Olympic champion. But everything changes when she's faced with sharing her ice time with ... Keep reading

Keep Reading Show less

HBO

'The Gilded Age' Returns This Weekend. Here's What You Need to Know.

Chloe Williams​

Oct 28, 2026

If you've been feeling absolutely distraught since the end of The Gilded Age season 3 — where the fate of Bertha (Carrie Coon) and George's (Morgan Spector) relationship was left up the air while Peggy (Denée Benton) got engaged to Dr. William Kirkland (Jordan Donica) — then you're definitely not alone. I have been beside myself waiting for new episodes to air so we can find out exactly what ... Keep reading

Keep Reading Show less

Amazon

14 Cozy Cottagecore Books To Curl Up With This Fall

Bre Avery

Oct 19, 2026

Some of my favorite books of all time fall into the “cottagecore” category. Reading, by nature, is one of the most cottagecore activities you can engage in, since it embodies the art of slow living. Additionally, immersing yourself in a book is extremely beneficial for your mental health, with studies showing that reading can lower your stress levels by as much as 68%. And isn’t that what the ... Keep reading

Keep Reading Show less

See More

How To Make Your Home Smell Like A Five-Star Hotel

Aura House

How To Make Your Home Smell Like A Five-Star Hotel

Brit + Co

Nov 05, 2026

Scent is so closely tied to memory that a single whiff can take you right back to that dream vacation. So why not make your home feel like your favorite getaway? The Aura House collection is a great place to start. Every nontoxic fragrance is expertly crafted and inspired by iconic hotels and destinations around the world. Bestsellers Collins, Coast and Dubai each capture a very different kind of ... Keep reading

Most Popular

Creativity & DIY

3 Easy Holiday Decor DIYs Made from Repurposed Cards

Irene Lee

Dec 13, 2016

Style & Shopping

This DIY Gym Bag Will Give Your Workout a Serious Upgrade

Irene Lee

Nov 15, 2016

Beauty & Skin Care

Why This Ogee Trio Is Our Top Pick at Sephora’s Holiday Savings Event

Brit + Co

Oct 21, 2026

Sponsored

This Nature-Inspired Kids’ Collection Is Perfect for All Your Spring Adventures

Brit Morin

Anjelika Temple

Mar 06, 2020

Parties

This Beauty and the Beast-Inspired Dinner Party Will Enchant the Entire Family

Irene Lee

Sep 09, 2016

©2026 Brit Media, Inc. All rights reserved.Terms of Service·Privacy Policy·Archives· Change Privacy Settings

STAY CONNECTED WITH BRIT + CO