It’s hard not to be completely charmed by anything and everything Harry Potter-related — just check out the Harry Potter (house-revealing) bath bombs, Harry Potter yoga, Harry Potter weddings, and (obvs) Harry Potter cocktails. That’s why we have no doubt that Harry Potter Cauldron Cakes are the yummiest thing to happen to the (IRL) wizarding world.

little boy reading Harry Potter book

Those who initially tried the dessert at Universal Studios’ Wizarding World of Harry Potter were given a chocolate mousse-filled, ganache-topped chocolate cake, whipped up at the Honeydukes and Sugarplums shops. Yum!

But a new version of the treat comes in a (reusable) mini cauldron with bright orange frosting flames bursting from the top.

While the original version of the treat cost a mere $3.95, the newer cake is quite a bit pricier at $9.95. Of course, the cauldron makes it much more Instagram-worthy (and you can use it again in the future to make more of your own little cauldron cakes), but you’ll have to decide for yourself if it’s worth an additional $6.

Check out this gallery of the entire magical experience to help you make up your mind…

What do you think about the Harry Potter Cauldron Cake? Would you pay nearly $10 for one? Let us know @BritandCo!

(h/t TIME; photo via Lisa Maree Williams/Getty)