Just when you think you have your candy addiction beat, M&M’s drops THREE new peanut flavors into our laps. After their incredibly successful (and delish) PSL candies last year, it looks like the confectioner is looking to spread its wings into the custom flavor territory once more. And we’re waiting with bated breath.

With the help of actor Tony Hale, M&M’s announced three delicious new flavors of Peanut M&M’s out now. The flavors come in time for the crunchy candy’s 75th anniversary and one of them will be here to stay. This is the first time in the company’s history that they’ve ever allowed fans to decide which products will hit the shelf. First time for everything, right?

Debuting Coffee Nut, Honey Nut and Chili Nut M&M’s, the company wants to know which of these three flavors are our favorite. With open online voting, Instagram hashtag #MMSFlavorVote or by texting the word ‘VOTE’ to 87654, you can let M&M’s know if you’re more a caffeine hound, honey junkie or spice lover. You can vote once a day online or via text, so there’s another excuse to try all three regularly… for scientific purposes, obviously.

In June, they’ll announce which of the three will be the last one standing, so we’d better get to testing and voting.

Will you try all the new Peanut M&M’s flavors? Tell us @Britandco!

(Photos via @mmschocolate)