There are some celebrity “twins” that jump right out at you (Katy Perry and Zooey Deschanel come to mind). But the latest lookalikes in Hollywood are a pair we never would’ve ever thought to link: Evan Rachel Wood and Avril Lavigne!

Though we’re not sure why or under what circumstances the universe gifted us with their union, the Westworld actress and the “Let Me Go” singer took an Instagram snap together that pretty much had us squealing with delight.

“I finally found the carrier of the other pendant I was given at birth,” Wood joked of a photo of the two girls looking eerily similar in specs. With their blue eyes, blonde hair, and exquisite bone structure, the two could EASILY pass for identical twins.

“I finally found my long lost sister,” Lavigne wrote of the same shot.

HOW did we never see this before!? Now all we need is a photo of the two of them donning matching outfits, like Aubrey Plaza and Elizabeth Olsen did over the weekend, and we’ll be all set. Please? Pretty please? With a cherry on top?!

Are you shocked by this new twinning development? Tell us over @BritandCo.

(Photos via Frazer Harrison + Kevork Djansezian/Getty)