After binge-watching Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life and spending days (or weeks) discussing what we had witnessed, we thought the buzz would be dying down by now. But those cheeky folks over at Netflix aren’t ready to put things to bed just yet. That’s because, with the newest story line ending with those monumental (and controversial) final four words (spoilers below!), Netflix just tweeted a HUGE HINT about the father of Rory Gilmore’s baby.

Gilmore Girls A Year in the Life _ Rory and Logan

Rory: “Mom?”

Lorelai: “Yeah?”

Rory: “I’m pregnant.”

BOOM! They were the four words that blew our minds. And while we were left cruelly hanging with no resolution, revelations or conclusion in sight, fans could only guess what Rory would do and who the father was.

Gilmore Girls A Year in the Life _ Rory and Paul

Since there were two men in the younger Gilmore’s life when she found out she was preggo (not to mention Jess, who also popped by), most fans are betting her boyfriend, Paul, or her ex, Logan.

Then Netflix went and did this…

Playing on the scene with April’s science fair project that led her to discover that Luke was her dad, we see Logan and Paul’s faces popped into the places of possible pops. The photo includes the caption, “Where’s an eighth grade science fair when you need one? #GilmoreGirls,” but perhaps just a paternity test is in order.

And while this may be Netflix keeping up the tease for A Year in the Life, fans are hoping this hints at more episodes that will explore Rory’s possible pregnancy. *fingers crossed*

Who do you think/hope is the father of Rory’s baby? @BritandCo!

(h/t Cosmopolitan; photos via Netflix)