The Conversation
20 Stuffed Mushroom Recipes For The Best Thanksgiving Appetizers
Nov 21, 2023
Mushrooms act as a wholesome, earthy base for easy, one-bite Thanksgiving appetizers. Once the stems are twisted off, the ‘shrooms can be filed with a host of flavorful toppings like bacon, cheese, and aromatic veggies, then roasted or slow-cooked until bubbly and tender. Start prepping your turkey, because we have irresistible stuffed mushroom recipes below.
Slow-Cooked, Stuffed Mushrooms
Feast your eyes on a stuffed mushroom that’s filled with spinach-artichoke dip. (via Brit + Co)
Easy Stuffed Mushrooms
If you don't have a ton of time to bake your mushrooms, this is literally the perfect Thanksgiving appetizer. It can be served cold, but between the onions, olives, cheese, and tomatoes, there are so many amazing flavors your guests won't even care. (via Brit + Co)
5-Ingredient-Stuffed Mushrooms
The star ingredient in these Asian-inspired bites is plum sauce, which offsets the savoriness of pork sausage, sesame oil, and mushrooms. (via A Spicy Perspective)
Jalapeño-Cream-Cheese-Stuffed Mushrooms
Looking for a healthier alternative to deep-fried jalapeño poppers? These baked bites, which still taste indulgent, fit the bill. (via Peas and Crayons)
Chorizo-Stuffed Mushrooms
These vibrant, slightly spicy ‘shrooms make a flavorful appetizer for a Mexican-inspired meal. (via The Real Food Dietitians)
Sausage-Stuffed Mushrooms With Hollandaise
These three-cheese hollandaise-drizzled mushrooms are the new brunch attraction in town. (via Foodie Crush)
Crab-Stuffed Mushrooms With Garlic and Gouda
Make a platter of these, and your seafood-lovin’ friends won’t know what hit them. (via Peas and Crayons)
French-Onion-Soup-Stuffed Mushrooms
These mushrooms pack all of the flavors of French onion soup, including the signature cheesy crust, into one convenient bite. (via The Veg Life)
Goat-Cheese-Stuffed Mushrooms Wrapped in Bacon
These cheesy mushrooms are wrapped in a crispy bacon hug. (via Port and Fin)
Spanakopita-Stuffed Mushrooms
Flaky, feta-rich spanakopita is a staple at cocktail parties. Enjoy a low-carb version by replacing the pastry with mushrooms. (via Wholesome Yum)
Easy Pizza Portobello Stuffed Mushrooms
These stuffed mushrooms are basically just mini pizzas, and what could be better than that? Nothing. (via The Girl on Bloor)
Vegetarian, Italian-Stuffed Mushrooms
You don’t need meat to give stuffed mushrooms a robust flavor. These get plenty of pizzazz from shallots, garlic, parmesan, and herbs. (via Bowl of Delicious)
Bacon-and-Blue-Cheese-Stuffed Mushrooms With Creamy Hot Sauce
These saucy bites will be a welcome addition to any spread, be it a game-day party or movie night. (via The Food Charlatan)
Vegan, Pesto-Stuffed Mushrooms
This guilt-free appetizer gives you a healthy dose of greens from spinach and basil. (via Hummusapien)
Shrimp-Stuffed Portobello Mushrooms
You’ll be transported to a little restaurant by the sea when you take a bite of these mushrooms. The breadcrumbs on top add a crunch that complements the tender shrimp. (via Little Spice Jar)
Italian, Sausage-Stuffed Mushrooms
These breakfast-friendly ‘shrooms would make a deliciously unexpected side to sweeter pancakes or French toast. (via The Chunky Chef)
Buffalo-Chicken-Stuffed Mushrooms
Whether or not you’re keto, you’ll find many things to enjoy about these low-carb, high-fat mushrooms like cream cheese, cheddar cheese, chicken, and a touch of hot sauce. (via My Life Cookbook)
Goat-Cheese-Stuffed Mushrooms
In this case, stuffed mushrooms are really just an excuse to eat ample bites of gooey goat cheese, and we’re all for it. (via Food Fanatic)
Pizza-Stuffed Mushrooms
If you ask us, you can have pizza without crust but never without cheese. Enjoy all the flavors of a meat lover’s pie in these easy, stuffed mushrooms. (via Plain Chicken)
Curry-Potato-Stuffed Mushrooms
Indian flavors, including garam masala and coconut milk, fill these white button mushrooms. (via The Pretty Bee)
Follow us on Pinterest for more stuffed mushroom recipes *and* more amazing Thanksgiving ideas!
This post has been updated.