Sometimes the best natural makeup look can be the result of a little DIY action in your bathroom. While we鈥檙e all about playing with food when it comes to a face mask or our lips (among other things), one YouTuber recently took homemade cosmetics down the cookie aisle and the results are鈥 interesting.

YouTuber Katharine Ward recently shared a new way to DIY mascara, and it involved everyone鈥檚 fave accessory to a glass of milk 鈥 Oreos (WHAT?!). On her account xxmakeupiscoolxx, Katharine details how you can turn a few ingredients (rubbing alcohol, primer and those cream-stuffed cookies) into a lengthening mascara that will leave everyone staring (just hopefully not because your lashes are clumpy鈥 or crumb-y).

oreo-mascara-Katharine-Ward

While we appreciate the teenage beauty vlogger鈥檚 creativity we are a little skeptical about the resulting look of the cookie-based cosmetic and how sanitary it is for Oreos to be that close to your eyeballs. Plus, as BuzzFeed points out, this DIY is a little pricey compared to a more hygienic drugstore product.

oreo-mascara-Katharine-Ward-3

We鈥檒l just stick with magazine eyeliner for creative eye makeup for now.

Would you try this (or other) food makeup hacks? Let us know in the comments.

(h/t Eater)