When news broke that we could finally find out what our very own patronus is via a Pottermore quiz, Harry Potter fans (who’ve been gobbling up the three new books from J.K. Rowling) were quick to see what incredible creature they were matched up with in this realm of magic and wonder. While some were totally thrilled, others were less than impressed — and still more were downright disappointed.

Pottermore Patronus

When we say allHarry Potter fans took the quiz, we surely meant it. J.K. herself ended up with a heron after taking the test, and others found themselves with magical, mythical patronus.

But not everyone was blessed with such enchanting creatures. Some were pretty disappointed with their common critters.

Joss Whedon wasn’t exactly thrilled with his weasel.

And salmon was just as unwelcome, TBH.

Really, who wants a mouse, or worse, a rat?!

Or an aardvark?

Though perhaps that’s slightly better than getting a shrew.

Or a mole?

Or a pig? Talk about disappointing.

We really all wanted something super cool.

But in the end, if you weren’t happy, you can always make your own.

What patronus did you get? Something cool or something disappointing? Tweet us @BritandCo!

(h/t Buzzfeed; photos via JKR/Pottermore Ltd. ™ Warner Bros.)