Well, that was short lived! Five months after their romance began, Hilary Duff and boyfriend Jason Walsh are reportedly donezo. Though they just got back from a tropical vacay in Hawaii (Reese Witherspoon would approve), any island magic they might have experienced apparently just wasn’t enough to keep them together.

WEST HOLLYWOOD, CA - AUGUST 21: Actress Hilary Duff and personal/celebrity trainer Jason Walsh attend 'Rise Nation Fitness Studio's Los Angeles Grand Opening' on August 21, 2015 in West Hollywood, California. (Photo by Mark Davis/Getty Images for Rise Nation)

We can’t say we’re entirely surprised — theirs definitely didn’t start out as a love story for the ages, after all: You might recall the brow-raising Halloween costumes that didn’t go over so hot with the public, for which they both issued public apologies.

But it wasn’t pilgrim-and-Indian backlash that drove these two apart.

According to sources for People magazine, their issues were moreso rooted in geography. “They aren’t on the same page,” the source says. “He wants to move to New York, but her life is in LA.”

That’ll do it! No matter how much you love someone, if the two of you can’t agree on life’s major milestones (like, for example, where to live), you’re bound to be headed for heartbreak.

While we’re sure Hil’s plenty sad, she seems to have the right idea when it comes to healing a potentially broken heart, at least — lots of QT with her own little cutie.

View this post on Instagram

Ahhhhh ❤️

A post shared by Hilary Duff (@hilaryduff) on

Just peep those adorable little baby feets she’s was chilling with last night. “Ahhhhh,” she wrote.

With cozy slippers to boot, it looks like a pretty solid breakup plan to us!

Are you sad to see these two split? Share with us @BritandCo.

(h/t E!, photos via Mark Davis/Getty)